To 3G or not to 3G?
Posted by admin on June 18th, 2008
I’m struggling now with the decision to upgrade from my $600 launch day 8gig iPhone to the brand new shiny 3G – GPS enabled $300 16gig iPhone. I’m really happy with my current iPhone and I’d love to have the faster radio and GPS capabilities but is the upgrade worth $200 or $300?
The two features that make the iPhone 3G a better device than the original is the new 3G radio and the GPS. The benefits of these two upgrades goes beyond just a faster data connection and knowing exactly where you are at all times. Are these two upgrades worth spending $200? Lets take a look at what these features will enable to iPhone 3G to do that the original iPhone could not.
3G: Most of the time I’m near a Wi-Fi connection. Which makes the iPhone’s new 3G connection moot. However, the iphone is best suited for use when you aren’t near a wi-fi connection. When you are in the middle of no where and find an odd shaped rock: well you need to inform your twitter followers, right? The introduction of third party applications make a faster radio that much more important.
Looking at the MLB.com application I can’t see a practical use for the streaming play-by-play baseball videos over edge. That application was designed for either wifi or 3G in mind. But it’s when you don’t have access to wifi when checking baseball scores would be most common. In the office or at home you’re either watching the game or watching the play-by-play gamecast on your computer. You don’t need the MLB application at that point. But when stuck in a restaurant and while checking the scores and I see that Manny just hit a huge home run I want to be able to watch that video. Edge speeds won’t cut it.
But the problem with 3G is that the AT&Ts 3G coverage is shockingly bad.
The coverage map lists my entire area (Southern Connecticut) as being 3G ready but as it stands right now I have enough trouble getting Edge service everywhere I go, especially in buildings. The first thing you need to do before even considering buying the 3G iPhone is to check the coverage map. People in big cities aren’t going to have a problem, but most other areas are going to have to stick with edge. http://www.wireless.att.com/coverageviewer/
GPS: The iPhone 3G comes with assisted GPS. Meaning that the GPS chip will use itself as little as possible in favor of cell towers. But with the GPS chip it’ll always find your exact location. The problem with the GPS is in software. As it stands now the SDK user agreement prevents the use of turn-by-turn directions. So Apple seems to want to exclusively use the GPS for location based services like the loopt social network. Which isn’t a poor use of the hardware, it just might not be worth the price of upgrading from the original model.
The battery life is also questionable. Steve expertly avoid
ed talking about how much battery the GPS was going to suck down from my multimedia device. Until I see reviews I don’t think I want GPS anywhere near my phone; turn by turn directions or not.
The other improvements to the iPhone also add value to the new model over the old. The plastic back is supposed to boost reception, which has been a problem compared to other phones. The volume on the speaker phone and standard ear piece is supposed to be improved. The phone is supposed to fit better in your hand. And it includes the flush headphone jack as opposed to the recessed headphone jack on the original hardware.
Are all of these improvements worth a $200 upgrade? If the 3G coverage was better then I wouldn’t hesitate to jump on the upgrade. But the poor quality of the 3G network tell me that I should wait till AT&T builds out their network to an exceptable size.
There is also the option of getting a bigger harddrive for another $100. That upgrade is very worth it, the 8gig harddrive has provided plenty of space for music and movies. But with the Application Store about to be released it’d be nice to have another 8 gigs. But $300 is still steep considering the lackluster shine of the other new features of the 3G iPhone.

Please don’t get me wrong. I recommend the iPhone 3G to anyone who wants the iPhone or anyone who needs a new iPod. Its an amazing deal! But should current iPhone owners upgrade? Well, if you are in a big city and can get constant 3G while away from a wi-fi access point. If you think that GPS location based services will be good navigating though the city then the iPhone 3G will give you that added bonus. If you have an iPhone and don’t get 3G in your area stick with your current phone and take advantage of the new features of the 2.0 software.
I remain undecided. I starting writing this to convince myself to buy the new iPhone. Now finished I seem to have pushed myself in the exact opposite direction that I intended. I’ll probably wait until the 32gig model comes out. Or wait a bit longer till the 3 generation hardware comes out. I’m sure it’ll include enough features to make upgrading a no brainer.





